When you’re charged with DUI (Driving Under the Influence), you might not realize that there can be two separate cases involved — one criminal and one civil. These cases may happen at the same time, but they have different purposes, rules, and outcomes. Understanding the difference between criminal and civil DUI cases can help you know what to expect and how to defend yourself.
What Is a Criminal DUI Case?
A criminal DUI case is handled in criminal court and focuses on whether you broke the law. In this case, the government (usually the state or city) charges you with a crime. The goal of the criminal case is to punish illegal behavior and protect public safety.
If you’re found guilty in criminal court, you may face penalties such as:
-
Jail time
-
Fines
-
Probation
-
Mandatory DUI school
-
Community service
-
Installation of an ignition interlock device (IID)
-
A permanent criminal record
A criminal case starts with an arrest and is followed by court appearances, a possible trial, and a verdict. You have the right to a lawyer, to remain silent, and to a fair trial by jury or judge.
Key Points:
-
Government is the one pressing charges.
-
Penalties can include jail or prison time.
-
You’re presumed innocent until proven guilty.
-
Requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
What Is a Civil DUI Case?
A civil DUI case is not about punishing you with jail or fines. Instead, it’s about regulating your driving privileges. This case is usually handled by a state department of motor vehicles (DMV) or similar agency. It deals with license suspension and related administrative penalties.
This kind of case usually starts if you refuse a breathalyzer test or fail a chemical test. In many states, this triggers automatic license suspension, even before your criminal trial starts. This is called administrative license suspension.
In a civil DUI case, you don’t face jail time, but you might:
-
Lose your driver’s license
-
Be required to attend alcohol education or treatment
-
Have to install an IID to get your license back
-
Pay administrative fees
Key Points:
-
Handled by DMV or similar agency, not the court.
-
Only affects your driving rights, not your criminal record.
-
No jail time involved.
-
Burden of proof is lower—often just preponderance of the evidence.
Timing: Which Case Happens First?
In most states, the civil case starts first. For example, if you fail a breathalyzer or refuse to take one, the DMV may suspend your license immediately. You usually have a short period (like 10–15 days) to request a hearing to fight the suspension.
The criminal case usually moves slower and may take weeks or months. However, the outcome of your criminal case doesn’t automatically cancel the civil penalties. Even if you’re found not guilty in criminal court, your license can still be suspended in the civil case.
Different Standards of Proof
One of the biggest differences between criminal and civil DUI cases is the standard of proof needed.
-
Criminal case: The government must prove you are guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, which is a high standard.
-
Civil case: The DMV only needs to show that it’s more likely than not (a preponderance of the evidence) that you drove under the influence or refused testing.
Because the civil case has a lower burden of proof, it’s often harder to win—even if you are fighting both cases at the same time.
Do You Need a Lawyer for Both?
Yes, it’s a good idea to have a lawyer for both cases. While a criminal DUI lawyer focuses on your court defense, they may also help with your DMV hearing. The two cases are different, but they can affect each other.
A skilled DUI lawyer knows how to:
-
Challenge faulty test results
-
Find mistakes in police procedures
-
Represent you at your license hearing
-
Negotiate lighter penalties
-
Help you keep your driving privileges
How the Two Cases Affect Each Other
While the two cases are separate, what happens in one can affect the other. For example:
-
If you plead guilty in criminal court, your license suspension in the civil case may be extended.
-
If your license is suspended in the civil case, the criminal court might still impose additional driving restrictions.
-
In some cases, the evidence from your DMV hearing can be used in your criminal case and vice versa.
Because of this, it’s important to treat both cases seriously.
Conclusion
A DUI arrest can lead to two different legal battles—a criminal case in court and a civil case through the DMV. The criminal case decides whether you broke the law and what punishment you face. The civil case handles your license and driving rights. These cases are separate but connected, and both can seriously affect your life. With the help of a qualified lawyer, you can understand the process, defend yourself properly, and work toward the best possible outcome.
